Train Travel: Canada vs USA

Amtrak Roomette

This fall, I spent a fair amount of time on the rails. After a 17-day spring transatlantic cruise, from Lima, Peru to San Diego, California, I booked a roomette and traveled from Los Angeles to Chicago (and then back again). The reason for the trip? For the first time, since retiring in 2017, my income tax return was mailed to my home address and not deposited into my bank account. I probably spent more on getting the return than I got from the return itself.

Which way should my head go?

The train ride included three daily meals. The cabin attendant came by morning, noon, and night, to find out when and where I wanted to eat. I did a mix of the main dining room and my cabin. The attendant also came by each day and night to convert the lower sitting area into a bed. I could have just had him make up the top bunk. But, the idea of climbing up and down all night, for bathroom breaks, changed my mind.

Via Rail Canada

On my way to a cruise from Vancouver to Tokyo, I booked VIA Rail’s legendary flagship transcontinental train from Toronto. “The Canadian” is a four-day, 4,466 kilometers, journey, across five provinces. This was my second time on the route. A few years before my retirement, I booked a berth on the train, traveling in the opposite direction. I remember passengers (from the other sleeper cars) walking through the corridor, going to the observation car or the dining room.

Time for bed!

Each evening, the seating area was converted into a bedroom. The food in the main dining room was fantastic. I remember spending a great deal of time in the Observation Car. The trip was totally worth the price. I was very fortunate that no one else purchased the seat opposite me. So, I was able to request the bottom bunk. The major difference between a berth and a cabin was not having a room to lock. It was odd just pulling a curtain shut and then listening to people walking back and forth all night.

Food Glorious Food

The food in the formal dining room on Via Rail made up for it! Amtrak has a very set menu that is often hit or miss. It’s better than the microwaved food going on in coach. But with only a few choices, on their breakfast, lunch, and dinner menus, the options are limited on long-haul trips. The dining room on Via Rail prepares scratch-cooked meals from Red Seal-certified chefs. On Amtrak, some dining room items (like hot dogs on the kids’ menu and sausage or bacon on the breakfast menu) are reheated.

Traditional Dining: My Way in my cabin.

Amtrak sleeper train meals are a mixed bag and a hot mess. There are different levels of dining, depending on the route. If your route offers Traditional Dining, your meals are chef-prepared and served on tables with white tablecloths.

Flexible Dining Meals

On the other hand, if you’re taking an Amtrak route offering what’s Flexible Dining, you will be served prepackaged microwaved meals. The meals in coach on Via Rail and Amtrak are also different. Via Rail’s coach meals were prepared by a cook. Amtrak coach meals are warmed up by a microwave.

Emergency Dining

There are also times on Amtrak when the dining car becomes completely non-functional and food operations fallback on standard Amtrak emergency procedures. I’ve heard of food (sandwiches or pizza) being ordered from a restaurant down the line and handed out to guests. On a train from St. Paul to Chicago, we were given heated up Beef Stew and emergency snack packs.

Coach Sleeping

I’ve had OK luck in coach, on Amtrak and Via Rail. On long runs, from Seattle to Chicago (for example), Amtrak put all the passengers going to Chicago in one car. That provided a first night’s sleep with no one seated next to us. On my coach run with Via Rail (Toronto to Vancouver), no one was seated next to me for the full duration of the trip.

Via Rail for the WIN

I was very surprised and pleased with two additional things, on Via Rail. First, at almost every “fresh air” stop, where passengers could get off the train and stretch their legs, a staff member came by and cleaned the train car. On a three-day Amtrak trip, the coach car was only cleaned once a day.

Gone, but not forgotten

My pre-cruise rail journey to Vancouver was, unfortunately, at the very end of VIA Rail’s “Artists on Board” Program. It offered complimentary or reduced-fare travel for up and coming professional musicians, in return for performing three times a day (in the different classes of accommodation) on board The Canadian (Toronto–Vancouver) and The Ocean (Montréal–Halifax). The program ended this year.

On Amtrak, I purchased their USA Rail Pass. The money I saved brought music to my ears! You get 10 travel segments (rides) in Coach class. Each train connection or transfer counts as a separate segment. Once you begin, you have 30 days to travel. Buyer beware: Amtrak only reserves a few seats for rail pass holders. I normally book my first three or four trips, as soon as I get the pass. Then, I book another two or three trips, in person, while waiting for my next train, at an Amtrak station. Ten train trips, for $500.00, were well worth my time! XOXO—GGT

Leave a Reply